Discussion in 'Linkin Park Chat' started by Azo117, May 1, 2007.
lyrically, "what i've done" wins, IMO.
Given Up is just a bit better IMO. It's just more my style than What I've Done, although WID is great in its own way.
But No more sorrow sound way better than both previous songs because of the anti war stuff and etc...
given up all the way
I actually like What I've Done a bit better because event htough Given up is ill witht he heavy parts, it kinda feels like it's missing something.Maybe something during the verses.It sounds kinda plain there.And what I've done, the only thing they couuld have done better was a solo.But then again the one they had was cool.It was good for the song.
I much prefer Given Up to What I've Done. Given Up is a more exiting and lively song. Although they are very different songs and both are great.
I actually thought What I've Done is their weakest live song ever.
Quite dissapointing actually.
On the other hand, Given Up is awesome live.
GU > NMS > WID
Hmm. Had to vote for WID, mainly cause we havn't heard the full studio version of Given up yet.
Dont get me wrong, GU is a terrific song & I'm more likely to play that than WID (mainly cause I'll be tired of WID when M2M comes out) But I think WID is one of their best (not THE best) but one of their best singles. The Piano & Guitar solo & Bridge make it for me.
Given Up is way better in my opinion, but both are great
- What I've done on all the way.
i love both songs soooooooooooooo much
i think its gonna be given up when it comes to the good beats and all
if its about the lyrics i chose what i've done
LOL necropostage from 07 much? Jk. I like GU a lot more, one of my favorite LP songs. I do love WID too though.
Separate names with a comma.