So the band should make music based on how commercially successful an album was, by trying to recreate it's sound? Instead of making the music they want to? Just to please a hand full of fans? I really can't see why anybody would want that. I'm quite happy to let them make the music they want to create. If I like it cool, if not then that's fine. I understand people want to grow at what they love to do, instead of beating a dead horse with a tired genre.