Discussion in 'Your Projects' started by Nikki, Jun 3, 2004.
ava - 10/10 very abstract
sig - 6/10 too monotone , font doesnt really fit in with it
Essentially the Rising Tied artwork cropped and resized, with some grungy text thrown in. I do like the artwork, however.
Simply a small square cropped from the artwork. It does, however, fit with the signature (obviously), and looks nice. Thank god you put a border.
Avatar: 7/10. I quite like the idea and colour. The text is rather hard to read and kind of smushed at the end. I do enjoy how it kind of messes with your eyes. :hypno:
Sig: 8.66/10. I like this one quite a bit. I like the idea, colour, and size. I think that you did a good job with the pictures of the bandmembers because you can actually make them out in detail. Over all a very nice sig.
...I personally think, if you get mine 3x...you should stop rating it. What is the use if it is only the same person? This is to see what other people think...or maybe if you have a new opinion, or some constructive critisism.
anyways, I give you a 5.5/10 for your sig. You need more and a bit better contrast.
I really like your avatar, but it does not go with your sig whatsoever, so I bump it down to an 7.5/10.
None of it flows.
8/10 for both. They have good effects and nice colours. Everything seems to flow and it matches quite nicely. I just don't like how the LP flashes, I find if a little annoying. But that may just be me.
On a side note: Why doesn't anyone ever post a reason for their rates anymore?!?! That is why there is this topic!To see what could be better for future reference and to see how nice yours is now. That is the point of this thread.
Sorry, i'm just getting a little annoyed. :chemist:
I won't say why, just to piss Holiday off.
needs more. I like your link. :chemist:
9/10 for the avatar. It would be 10 but it has absolutely nothing to do with the sig.
4/10 for the sig. I don't really like the color, and I think it needs to be centered. It doesn't flow well either, and I don't like the text.
Unrelated: That is the 4th time you've rated Holiday's sig. You might want to let someone else do it next time so she can get another opinion.
Thank you. Really, thank you.
9/10 for you Avatar because I really like it. Its kind of abstract, but not really. lol
7.8/10 for your sig. I really like the colour, and it is a good picture. Also, that is quite a funny quote at the bottom.
You're probebly right.
sig - ava - 9/10 both look great with the pixelated effect. the fact that they match are even better. very nice!
7/10 - It's BTH. Nice positioning of the girl but otherwise plain.
Avatar : 9/10 I can't tell what it is, but it looks cool.
Sig : 7/10 It's alright, but the text is kinda hard to read. No relation to the avatar. I like the blue around Chester, but other than that it's pretty plain.
Kind crappy though.
Sig: 8/10 Awesome looking, but I don't like the way all of the band members' faces have been editted. Otherwise it gets the thumbs up from me.
sig: 8/10 I love how everything is black and white except the flowers. Nice work.
10/10 for Avatar. I like the concept.
9/10 for the sig. Everything is awesome except the for the text. If it stood out it would be better.
sig: 7/10 The mirror image thing is intesting, but the image is kind of plain.
ava: 7/10 I don't think it has anything to do with the sig, and it's kind of small, but it still looks good.
Separate names with a comma.