I signed up to defend Amy Lee, but it appears that Casey blew it out of proportion... Anyways, I'll just go on with my rant. Any of you who may think that Amy Lee is a "poser", probably think so because she's been labelled as Gothic. Whether she is or not, I myself do not know. But the fact remains, that being Gothic doesn't mean that you have to hate everything, and want to die. IN fact, as any REAL Goth will tell you, being Gothic is about finding the beauty in things. It's about finding the beauty in love, as well as hate. Goths tend to be very romantic people, the real ones, anyways. Amy Lee's lyrics reflect this perfectly, as listening to Evanescence's CD "Fallen" can really shed light for most, on what a REAL Goth is. Amy Lee has done something that only one other person has managed to do, and that is to take the concept of being Gothic, and stay true to it. So, in conclusion, Amy Lee is not a poser... the poser's are in fact those who choose to call themselves Gothic, without really knowing what it is to be of such nature.
White Pony, that was extremely uncalled for. I'm not sure if you feel the same way that the person who built that site does, but you're being warned for bashing Gothics anyway. They have their beliefs and if you don't like it, tough.
http://maddox.xmission.com/gothics.html [/b][/quote] That is undoubtebly the most ignorant thing that I have ever read. #1...I myself am Straight Edge. I don't drink, I don't do drugs, and I won't have sex until I can genuinely say that it was love making. #2...most of us don't act depressed, unless we're feeling it. When I act like something, it's because I'm feeling it. If I get dumped, I'm going to be depressed. If I get paid, I'm going to be happy. I act just like any person who doesn't try to be someone else. I have no problem debating my way of life with people...what I do have a problem with, is when someone's arguement is riddled with ignorance.
Just don't get this topic closed, . How does everyone feel about Good Charlotte, do you think there posers?
Everyone's going to attack me when I say this, but I don't care; it's my opinion and I hold strong by it: Yes, I think Good Charlotte are posers.
Your opinion... Edit: I was just waiting for someone to bring up Good Charlotte in this poser crap. :whistle:
The only reason I did was because I've heard alot of people saying they were. I don't think Good Charlotte are posers, I like them.