It's BLATANTLY my least favorite. M2M is the only LP album I can say I don't love. A few songs were gems. Little Things Give You Away, Bleed It Out, In pieces. Other then that, all of those songs can go away
MtM and ATS are the only two LP albums that I actually listen to now. I pretty much like all the songs from MtM which is quite rare for me as there are songs on each LP album that I despise. My favourite songs are LOATR, BIO and SOTD. I’m a sucker for the “softer” LP songs so this album works well for me.
The better songs on there are easily some of their best full stop, the weaker ones aren't so good. I think it was still a step up from the previous album though, and it's understandable that it seems kind of muddled and confused in places considering it was where they started to make more wholesale changes to their music after about a decade of not varying it very much.
If you asked me to pick Meteora or Minutes to Midnight, I couldn't decide. They both have different pros and cons. Hybrid Theory is much better than both of them IMO and ATS tops everything.