Discussion in 'News' started by Derek, Apr 28, 2014.
Would that make them guilty all the same?
They'd certainly be too sick to be ashamed.
Where were the screams then? O:
You said every song included screaming except for AFN O:
This isn't Meteora.
He said every song but AFN and GATS (not sure if he actually said this but I believe this is song Derek said was semi-screaming)
I thought that you also said GATS was the Borderline screamy one o:
Wait, that means only KTTK, Rebellion have actual screaming?
AFN - No screams
GATS - No screams
UIG - No screams
Wastelands - No screams
KTTK - Screams
Rebellion - Screams
and turtleguy said that there only was 1 other Song with screams ._.
3 songs with screaming in total on their heaviest Album?
Well i am not saying that its not only heavy because of screaming but how is it then heavier than HT/Meteora?
Even Living things had 3 Songs with screaming
You don't need screaming to be heavy. Duh.
Metallica is heavy and not once has James Hatfield screamed.
Never said Chester didn't shout/yell in wastelands. He does growl a line or two.
UIG has a scream at the end of the song. Wasteland according to Derek's last post has a scream. TurtleGuy said 5-6 songs have screaming in it. If 6, that's half the album. War sounds like it has screaming. KTTK definitely has screaming.
2 songs don't have vocals. That leaves 10 songs left. If the higher end of TurtleGuys statement is correct that would be 6/10. Which is 3/5th or 60% of the songs with vocals. Which is a high percentage.
EDIT: and even if it is the lower end of his statement that's still 5/10 of the songs with vocals. Which is 50% which is not bad at all. And its definitely more than the last 3 albums. They aren't gonna pull a Suicide Silence and scream 24/7.
I dont mean short screams at the end of the song i mean real screams like in qwerty
Well, that's nice!
I never said it isnt heavy without screams
in fact i said the opposite at the end of my post
That wasn't the point I was trying to make. The main part of my post was correcting your incorrect facts to enlighten you that there is in fact more than 3 songs with screaming on 'The Hunting Party' and quite possible double the amount.
And stats really put it in prospective. If 60% of the songs with vocals have screaming, that is a great percentage. Visuals often help
I remember when you asked TurtleGuy :"So only one song more with screaming since the sampler? That makes 5/6 Songs with screaming"
But we know, the sampler only has 3 Songs with screaming, and then there is the other song he said
Wtf i am not getting anything right now please enlight me again ._.
Is "screaming" really that important? Rammstein is heavy as fuck and Till does thick growls at best.
All clean vocals, still heavy.
No, TurtleGuy wrote a post that specially said "4-5 songs with screaming." However, he did not count UIG as screaming even though there clearly is a scream at the end of the song and it counts as a scream. Also, Derek confirmed 4 of the songs in the sampler had screaming.
So I took his "4-5" and upped it to "5-6" which is correct because UIG has screaming even though he didn't count it. I can go find the post and quote it if you want.
I cant listen to rammstein because i am german and i think it sounds stupid
Also if you think rammstein is heavy, i could tell you some of my favourite bands which make everything you ever heard sound like soft cuddle songs
F.e. Infant Annihilator - Anal Prolapse suffocation or any other song by them
And yes, this is a real Drummer Not a machine i know him personally
And could you please stop telling me that music doesnt need screaming to be heavy? I said it myself in my FIRST post.
But thank you for your examples
I am German too and i think Rammstein is pretty cool , so your argument is wrong ^^
They have some pretty cool songs. And a really nice Live-Show.
Just because your band is heavy does not make the other bands any less heavy. One band might be more heavy than another but that doesn't change the fact that other bands are still heavy
No its not, its my opinion and i hate Songs that are german except for kollegah and farid bang because i think it Sounds stupid
And rammstein lyrics are pretty dumb
Its also his opinion that he likes Rammstein
I personally love Rammstein
Separate names with a comma.