It's close but GATS is IMO a little bit better. The bridge in ALITS isn't that interesting and we all know that we would rather just have a full song based on Mike singing the verses Don't get me wrong both are amazing tracks and this opinion may change - but right now I feel like the "heavyness" can feel a bit unnecessary at times. Both songs are 9/10 anyway. Fucking love em.
A Line in the Sand reminds me of Under the Sea [video=youtube;jgA2xo0HYrE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jgA2xo0HYrE[/video]
A Line In The Sand. It has beautiful riffs and Chester's screams are really awesome. But Guilty All The Same only has good intro, rap and outro and Chester doesn't sing really good.
ALITS just because its a little more epic and free-flowing. One thing I really don't dig about the song though is that little spoken wordy breakdown by Mike.