I haven't gotten to play the game yet (I thought I'd pre-ordered it but I was wrong so I have to wait a couple days) so I can't speak to whether or not it sucks, but I can say for a certainty that the thousands of people of r/fallout absolutely love the game. I'm sure there's the odd few who don't, but you'll have that with any AAA game release. Anyway, aside from the ending of Mass Effect 3, both ME2 and ME3 were incredible games. I'm not really sure what you're talking about there. They made gunplay and combat in general better in ME2 and ME3 but they didn't take away the adventuring aspects of the RPG.