Amy and Shaun planned to re-record "Broken" as like a B-side for their new album, but Wind-Up "fucked it up" by forcing the song to be completely re done and put as a track on the album. And that last generallizion was completely unneeded.
Okay, first of all, the first Broken fucking sucked. Period. Secondly, they planned to record Broken as a duet in the first place. Thirdly, show me a quote where Amy Lee has claimed to be goth.
I agree with your second paragraph, in that Seether are probably only going to be known for the Broken Ft. Amy Lee track, well, especially over here in the UK anyway. As for the goth posers who hurt themselves for attention, i agree, but that's a different subject matter all together. Anyway, as for my opinion on the article, i don't see the problem with it. I personally agree with Amy in that Velvet Revolver are nothing special. All of us voice opinions on who we don't like, i don't see why it should be any different for someone in the spotlight.
Velvet Revolver are nothing special. If you want to piss and moan about what a frontperson says about another band, try this: Scott Weiland assaulted his wife a number of times, then accused KoRn of being sexist. Before you call me a 'fangirl' simply because I oppose you on this topic, may I just point out that... 1. I detest Evanescence and I'm not much of a KoRn fan. 2. Stone Temple Pilots and Guns N' Roses are, to me, two of the greatest bands of the last two decades.
the thing is your opinion doesn't make something a fact. her saying Velvet Revolver is nothing special is her opinion and it is stuck up because by saying that its also kind of saying her band is something special.
You know, you're becoming very annoying. Number one, it's a fucking opinion and you're not going to change it. Number two, just because we agree with it does not make it fact and no one fucking said it was fact. Number three, stop being a childish noob. You're making yourself look foolish by coming in here trying to get us to not agree with Amy Lee just because you seem to be offended that she bashed a band you like. Get the fuck over it, please.
You know, you're becoming very annoying. Number one, it's a fucking opinion and you're not going to change it. Number two, just because we agree with it does not make it fact and no one fucking said it was fact. Number three, stop being a childish noob. You're making yourself look foolish by coming in here trying to get us to not agree with Amy Lee just because you seem to be offended that she bashed a band you like. Get the fuck over it, please. [/b][/quote] actually i dont like Velvet Revolver. I'm not trying to convert your opinions. It seems this argument started because i said it was a stuck up thing to say, and then the Evanescence lovers came and flamed me, stating things i never said.
actually i dont like Velvet Revolver. I'm not trying to convert your opinions. It seems this argument started because i said it was a stuck up thing to say, and then the Evanescence lovers came and flamed me, stating things i never said. [/b][/quote] Dude, just shut up before you get banned! Just keep your opinion to yourself!!
actually i dont like Velvet Revolver. I'm not trying to convert your opinions. It seems this argument started because i said it was a stuck up thing to say, and then the Evanescence lovers came and flamed me, stating things i never said. [/b][/quote] No one fucking flamed you, stop overreacting.
Ok, If you got flamed, Please tell me where. I did read the whole thread and there was no flaming until you called Mark a dope.
Woah. I dont see why youre getting so defensive. Chill out, its not that big a deal. No one flamed you, they just dont agree with you and youre flipping out about it. Chill out, now.
That was, quite possibly, the most close-minded thing I think I've ever heard. Not once has she said she was goth, and I don't even think she resembles any gothic profiles at all. A little black eyeliner and some tattered dresses and she's goth? Let's get real. That was an asinine generalization. As for Amy being like "all the other wannabe goth posers that love to hurt themselves for fucking attention", I'm not even going to elaborate further than "That's absolutely ridiculous". And CJ, I'd read my "step one of debating" again. Read carefully. I did not once say that my opinion (or Amy Lee's) was a fact, and I also said I respected your opinion. If I were you, I'd stop spitting out desperate phrases and making myself look ridiculous. And you might want to look over the definition of "flaming" again. No one called you a name or insulted you. I simply disagreed with you. If you want to become this raging maniac everytime someone disagrees with you, be my guest. But think about how it makes you look.
But you can just tell by looking at her and...fuck, i'm just going to shut up...there's no god damn sense into keeping this up!
But you can just tell by looking at her and...fuck, i'm just going to shut up...there's no god damn sense into keeping this up! [/b][/quote] Wow. I didnt know anyone could be so stereotypical. Just because she dresses a certain way, does NOT make her a goth. She just has her own style. Unfortunately we live in a world where having your own style is classified into something anyway/.
But you can just tell by looking at her and...fuck, i'm just going to shut up...there's no god damn sense into keeping this up! [/b][/quote] Well, as I said; "some black eyeliner and some tattered dresses and she's goth?". Come on, now, let's get real. That's like me saying every guy with a pink shirt is gay, or everybody with red hair is from Ireland. You shouldn't be so quick to judge. Broaden your horizons.
I've noticed the staff likes to say, "that was the most *enter a list of insulting adjectives here* I've ever heard." Carl Johnson, I believe you're mad because we're defending Amy. Hey, I said she was right but then I said her band wasn't that special. So, I'm different. See? We're not all here to kiss her booty like you think.