At this point in time, since I haven't heard this album. His review is as good as any review out there. It's giving me an insight on what's comin up. And the movie to album comparison.. is different. Unless it was a musical then yea lol. And he described the album which is what I want! While it was negative, it at least backs up the german reviewer on his taste and confirms the truth behind what turtleguy said and the MTV review. He was just negative about it.