The Big Song Rating Thread

Discussion in 'Linkin Park Chat' started by Ryanz, Jun 7, 2017.

  1. #1

    Ryanz Member

    Mar 12, 2016
    Likes Received:

    A couple weeks have passed since OML's release so i think that now i can do this.
    Also, i haven't posted anything for a year.

    Hybrid Theory: 7,5
    Papercut: 7,5
    One Step Closer: 6,5
    With You: 8
    Points Of Authority: 7,5
    Crawling: 7
    Runaway: 6
    By Myself: 7,5
    In The End: 7
    A Place For My Head: 7,5
    Forgotten: 8
    Cure For The Itch: 7,5
    Pushing Me Away: 7,5
    My December: 7
    High Voltage: 8

    Meteora: 7
    Foreword+Don't Stay: 6
    Somewhere I Belong: 7
    Lying From You: 7
    Hit The Floor: 6,5
    Easier To Run: 7
    Faint: 7,5
    Figure.09: 7
    Breaking The Habit: 8,5
    From The Inside: 7,5
    Nobody's Listening: 6
    Session: 7
    Numb: 7,5

    Minutes To Midnight: 8 (it's my personal opinion, don't get angry)
    Wake+Given Up: 7,5
    Leave Out All The Rest: 7
    Bleed It Out: 8
    Shadow Of The Day: 7,5
    What I've Done: 7
    Hands Held High: 8
    No More Sorrow: 7,5
    Valentine's Day: 6,5
    In Between: 8
    In Pieces: 8
    The Little Things Give You Away: 8,5
    Across The Line: 7,5
    No Roads Left: 8

    A Thousand Suns: 9
    The Requiem+The Radiance+Burning In The Skies: 8
    Empty Spaces+When They Come For Me: 7,5
    Robot Boy: 8
    Jornada Del Muerto: 7
    Waiting For The End: 9,5
    Blackout: 8,5
    Wretches And Kings: 8
    Wisdom, Justice And Love+Iridescent: 7,5
    Fallout+The Catalyst: 8,5
    The Messenger: 6,5

    Living Things: 7,5
    Lost In The Echo: 7,5
    In My Remains: 7,5
    Burn It Down: 7,5
    Lies Greed Misery: 6,5
    I'll Be Gone: 7
    Castle Of Glass: 7,5
    Victimized: 7
    Roads Untraveled: 8
    Skin To Bone: 7
    Until It Breaks: 7,5
    Powerless: 8

    The Hunting Party: 7,5
    Keys To The Kingdom: 8
    All For Nothing: 7
    Guilty All The Same: 7,5
    The Summoning: 7
    War: 6,5
    Wastelands: 6,5
    Until It's Gone: 6
    Rebellion: 7
    Mark The Graves: 7,5
    Drawbar: 7,5
    Final Masquerade: 7,5
    A Line In The Sand: 9

    One More Light: 8
    Nobody Can Save Me: 7,5
    Good Goodbye: 7
    Talking To Myself: 7
    Battle Symphony: 7
    Invisible: 8
    Heavy: 6,5
    Sorry For Now: 8,5
    Halfway Right: 7,5
    One More Light: 8,5
    Sharp Edges: 8,5

    Bonus(demos and songs from other albums)
    And One: 7,5
    Stick And Move: 7
    Fuse: 7,5
    Reading My Eyes: 7
    Slip: 7,5
    Blue: 7,5
    Part Of Me: 7,5
    Carousel: 7,5
    Dedicated: 7
    She Couldn't: 8
    Pts.Of.Athrty: 7
    Frgt/10: 7,5
    Krwlng: 8
    My Dsmbr: 8
    What We Don't Know: 7,5
    Pretend To Be: 7,5
    New Divide: 7,5
    Blackbirds: 8
    QWERTY: 7
    A Light That Never Comes: 7
    Darker Than Blood: 5
    Captain-EO likes this.
  2. #2

    Virgocore Well-Known Member

    Mar 3, 2017
    Likes Received:

    Hybrid Theory
    Papercut: 10 out of 10
    One Step Closer: 8 out of 10
    With You: 5 out of 10
    Points Of Authority: 6 out of 10
    Crawling: 9 out of 10
    Runaway: 6 out of 10
    By Myself: 3 out of 10
    In The End: 9 out of 10
    A Place For My Head: 9 out of 10
    Forgotten: 7 out of 10
    Cure For The Itch: 7 out of 10
    Pushing Me Away: 6 out of 10


    Don't Stay: 7 out of 10
    Somewhere I Belong: 5 out of 10
    Lying From You: 9 out of 10
    Hit The Floor: 6 out of 10
    Easier To Run: 7 out of 10
    Faint: 10 out of 10
    Figure.09: 8 out of 10
    Breaking The Habit: 10 out of 10
    From The Inside: 6 out of 10
    Nobody's Listening: 8 out of 10
    Session: 4 out of 10
    Numb: 8 out of 10

    Minutes To Midnight
    Wake: 7 out of 10
    Given Up: 10 out of 10
    Leave Out All The Rest: 10 out of 10
    Bleed It Out: 10 out of 10
    Shadow Of The Day: 10 out of 10
    What I've Done: 10 out of 10
    Hands Held High: 7 out of 10
    No More Sorrow: 10 out of 10
    Valentine's Day: 10 out of 10
    In Between: 7 out of 10
    In Pieces: 10 out of 10
    The Little Things Give You Away: 10 out of 10
    Ryanz likes this.
  3. #3

    Sasuke Modern Prog enjoyer LPA Super Member

    May 22, 2012
    Likes Received:

    Xero 4
    Rhinestone 4
    Reading My Eyes 6.5
    Stick And Move 5
    Fuse 3

    Hybrid Theory EP 6.5

    Carousel 6
    Step Up 6
    And One 8
    High Voltage 2
    Part Of Me 9

    Hybrid Theory 4
    Papercut 5
    One Step Closer 2
    With You 6
    Points of Authority 5
    Crawling 2
    Runaway 1
    By Myself 5
    In the End 3
    A Place for My Head 6.5
    Forgotten 6
    Cure for the Itch 4
    Pushing Me Away 5

    Meteora 4
    Don't Stay 4
    Somewhere I Belong 3
    Lying from You 5
    Hit the Floor 4
    Easier to Run 5
    Faint 5
    Figure.09 5
    Breaking the Habit 8
    From the Inside 4
    Nobody's Listening 5
    Session 7
    Numb 3

    Minutes to Midnight 8
    Given Up 7.5
    Leave Out All the Rest 5
    Bleed It Out 7
    Shadow of the Day 5
    What I've Done 5
    Hands Held High 7
    No More Sorrow 7
    Valentine's Day 8.5
    In Between 7.5
    In Pieces 9.5
    The Little Things Give You Away 11
    No Roads Left 9.5

    A Thousand Suns 10
    Burning in the Skies 9.5
    When They Come for Me 10
    Robot Boy 10
    Waiting for the End 8
    Blackout 10
    Wretches and Kings 10
    Iridescent 8.5
    The Catalyst 10
    The Messenger 7

    Living Things 8.5
    Lost in the Echo 7.5
    In My Remains 7
    Burn It Down 5
    I'll Be Gone 6
    Castle of Glass 9.5
    Victimized 7
    Roads Untraveled 10
    Skin to Bone 9
    Until It Breaks 10
    Tinfoil/Powerless 9

    The Hunting Party 8
    Keys to the Kingdom 7
    All for Nothing 5
    Guilty All the Same 7.5
    War 5
    Wastelands 5
    Until It's Gone 4.5
    Rebellion 6
    Mark the Graves 10
    Drawbar 8
    Final Masquerade 10
    A Line in the Sand 8

    One More Light 8.5
    Nobody Can Save Me 10
    Good Goodbye 5.5
    Talking to Myself 7
    Battle Symphony 6
    Invisible 7
    Heavy 5.5
    Sorry for Now 10
    Halfway Right 9
    One More Light 9
    Sharp Edges 9.5

    Remix & other albums:

    Reanimation 6
    Pts.Of.Athrty 5
    Enth E Nd 0
    P5hng Me A*wy 8.5
    Plc.4 Mie Hæd 5
    X-Ecutioner Style 3
    H! Vltg3 2.5
    Wth>You 6
    Ppr:Kut 3
    Rnw@y 2
    My<Dsmbr 6.5
    By_Myslf 5
    Kyur4 Th Ich 5
    1stp Klosr 7
    Krwlng 8

    Recharged: 3

    A Light That Never Comes 6
    Castle Of Glass (M. Shinoda Remix) 7
    Victimized (M. Shinoda Remix) 6
    I'll Be Gone (Vice Remix feat. Pusha T) 8
    Skin to Bone (Nick Catchdubs Remix feat. Cody B. Ware and Ryu) 6
    Until It Breaks (Money Mark Headphone Remix) 6
    A Light That Never Comes (Rick Rubin Reboot) 4
    (Never liked the other remixes, and I don't even remember them lmao)

    Colision Couse: 3

    Dirt Off Your Shoulder/Lying From You 3
    Big Pimpin'/Papercut 6
    Jigga What/Faint 4
    Numb/Encore 4
    Izzo/In The End 0
    Points Of Authority/99 Problems/One Step Closer 5.5
    (I can't stand Jay-Z tbh :lol:)


    She Couldn't 7
    My December 5
    Dedicated 4
    High Voltage (remix) 6
    QWERTY 6
    Across the Line 6
    What We Don't Know: 7
    I Have Not Begun 5
    Pretend to Be 9
    Slip 4
    Blue 4
    So Far Away 6
    Primo 10
    Animals 5
    Chance of Rain 8
    TooLeGit 4

    Other Songs:
    It's Goin' Down 5.5
    New Divide: 5
    Not Alone 4
    Blackbirds 5
    We Made It 2
    Darker Than Blood 6
    Things in My Jeep 6

    LOL I just realized that I dislike many LP songs :rofl:
    Last edited: Jun 7, 2017
    Ryanz likes this.
  4. #4

    Blake Leave a Trace LPA Super Member

    Mar 25, 2012
    Likes Received:

    I don't like rating songs with numbers so here is my tier system for each release starting backwards from One More Light all the way to HTEP. No non-album songs are included in my list. Everything is standard except the inclusion of My December and High Voltage.

    One More Light:

    SS: Sorry for Now, One More Light, Nobody Can Save Me
    S: Halfway Right, Sharp Edges
    A: Talking to Myself, Good Goodbye
    B: Battle Symphony, Invisible
    C: Heavy

    The Hunting Party:
    SS: Rebellion, Mark the Graves, Final Masquerade
    A: A Line In the Sand
    B: Drawbar, Guilty All the Same
    D: Wastelands
    F: Keys To the Kingdom, War, All For Nothing, The Summoning, Until It's Gone

    Living Things:
    SS: Lost In the Echo, In My Remains, Lies Greed Misery, Castle of Glass, Victimized, Roads Untraveled, Skin to Bone, Powerless
    B: Burn It Down, I'll be Gone, Tinfoil
    C: Until It Breaks

    A Thousand Suns:
    SS: Waiting For The End, The Catalyst, Iridescent
    S: Blackout, Wretches and Kings
    A: Burning In the Skies, When They Come For Me
    B: The Messenger
    C: The Requiem, The Radiance, Empty Spaces, Jornada Del Muerto, WJL, Fallout
    F: Robot Boy

    Minutes to Midnight:
    SS: Given Up, Leave Out All the Rest, Bleed It Out, In Between, In Pieces
    A: What I've Done, Hands Held High, Valentine's Day
    B: Wake, No More Sorrow, The Little Things Give You Away

    SS: Somewhere I Belong, Lying From, Faint, Breaking the Habit, From the Inside, Numb
    S: Foreword, Don't Stay, Figure.09, Nobody's Listening
    A: Easier to Run
    B: Session
    C: Hit The Floor

    Hybrid Theory:
    SS: Papercut, One Step Closer, Crawling, In the End, A Place For My Head, Pushing Me Away
    S: Points of Authority
    A: With You, Runaway, My December
    B: Forgotten
    C: By Myself, Cure for the Itch
    D: High Voltage

    Hybrid Theory EP:
    SS: And One
    A: Part of Me
    B: Carousel, Step Up
    D: Technique, High Voltage

    This lines up 100% accurate with my rankings of LP releases:
    Living Things
    Hybrid Theory=Minutes to Midnight
    A Thousand Suns
    One More Light
    Hybrid Theory EP
    The Hunting Party
  5. #5

    Captain-EO Also Prog Nerd Now, Thanks Gibs LPA Super Member

    Nov 3, 2014
    Likes Received:

    Sticking to the system @Blake used, this is how mine goes (at the moment of course). For simplicity's sake, bonus tracks that are included on deluxe editions are part of the albums here.

    One More Light:
    SS: Sorry for Now, Invisible, Nobody Can Save Me
    S: One More Light, Sharp Edges
    A: Battle Symphony, Good Goodbye
    B: Halfway Right
    C: Heavy
    F: Talking to Myself

    The Hunting Party:
    SS: All for Nothing, Mark the Graves, Final Masquerade
    S: Keys to the Kingdom
    A: Guilty All the Same
    B: Drawbar, Until It's Gone
    C: Wastelands, The Summoning
    F: Rebellion, War

    SS: Skin to Bone (Nick Catchdubs Remix)
    S: A Light That Never Comes (Rick Rubin Reboot)
    A: A Light That Never Comes, Powerless (Enferno Remix)
    B: Until It Breaks (Datsik Remix), Until It Breaks (Money Mark Headphone Remix), I'll Be Gone (Vice Remix)
    C: Victimized (M. Shinoda Remix), Roads Untraveled (Rad Omen Remix), I'll Be Gone (Schoolboy Remix)
    D: Castle of Glass (M. Shinoda Remix), Burn It Down (Tom Swoon Remix)
    F: Lost in the Echo (Killsonik Remix), Lies Greed Misery (Dirtyphonics Remix)

    Living Things:
    SS: Until It Breaks, In My Remains, Skin to Bone
    S: Powerless, Lost in the Echo,
    A: Roads Untraveled, Castle of Glass
    B: Burn It Down, Tinfoil
    C: I'll Be Gone
    D: Victimized
    F: Lies Greed Misery

    A Thousand Suns:
    SS: Waiting For The End, When They Come for Me, Blackout, Robot Boy
    S: Wretches and Kings, Jornada del Muerto, Wisdom Justice and Love
    A: The Messenger, The Requiem, The Radiance, Fallout, Empty Spaces, Blackbirds

    Minutes to Midnight:
    SS: Leave Out All the Rest, In Between, Valentine's Day
    S: The Little Things Give You Away, Wake, In Pieces, No Roads Left, Across the Line
    A: Given Up, Hands Held High, Shadow of the Day
    B: No More Sorrow, Bleed It Out

    Collision Course:
    SS: Points of Authority/99 Problems/One Step Closer
    S: Izzo/In the End
    A: Dirt Off Your Shoulder/Lying from You, Numb/Encore
    C: Jigga What/Faint
    F: Big Pimpin'/Papercut

    SS: Easier to Run, Breaking the Habit, Numb
    S: Lying from You, From the Inside
    A: Session, Hit the Floor, Faint
    B: Foreword, Don't Stay
    C: Figure.09, Somewhere I Belong
    D: Nobody's Listening

    SS: Krwlng, P5hng Me A*wy
    S: 1stp Klosr, H! Vltg3
    A: Frgt/10, Opening, My<Dsmbr, Ntr\Mssion
    B: Ppr:Kut, Kyur4 Th Ich
    C: By_Myslf, Wth>You, Rnw@y, [Chali], [Stef], [Riff Raff]
    D: Enth E Nd, Plc.4 Mie Haed
    F: Pts.Of.Athrty, X-Ecutioner Style, Buy Myself

    Hybrid Theory:
    SS: Papercut, With You, My December
    S: Crawling, Pushing Me Away
    A: Runaway
    B: Forgotten
    C: One Step Closer, Cure for the Itch
    D: High Voltage, By Myself
    F: Points of Authority, A Place for My Head, In the End

    Singles and Other Studio Releases:
    SS: Final Masquerade (Acoustic)
    S: Not Alone, The Last Line
    A: Issho Ni, It Goes Through
    B: White Noise
    C: Devil's Drop
    F: New Divide


    If we take all the D's and F's (below average), we get a pretty good list of my least-favorite Linkin Park tracks. We also see my distaste for a good bit of Hybrid Theory.

    Last edited: Jun 8, 2017
  6. #6

    Deliveranze Well-Known Member

    Jan 25, 2016
    Likes Received:

    Hybrid Theory EP 8.5/10
    Carousel 7
    Step Up 8
    And One 9
    High Voltage 7
    Part of Me 9

    Hybrid Theory 7/10
    Papercut 8.5
    One Step Closer 4
    With You 6.5
    Points of Authority 5
    Crawling 8
    Runaway 5.5
    By Myself 7.5
    In The End 10
    A Place For My Head 6.5
    Forgotten 10
    Cure For The Itch 7
    Pushing Me Away 7.5
    My December 9
    High Voltage (Remix) 8.5

    Meteora 9/10

    Don't Stay 4
    Somewhere I Belong 5
    Lying From You 10
    Hit The Floor 7
    Easier To Run 8.5
    Faint 9
    Figure .09 6.5
    Breaking The Habit 5.5
    From The Inside 7
    Nobody's Listening 9
    Session 7
    Numb 10

    Minutes To Midnight 10/10
    Wake 6
    Given Up 6
    Leave Out All The Rest 8
    Bleed It Out 9
    Shadow of The Day 8
    What I've Done 10
    Hands Held High 9.5
    No More Sorrow 7
    Valentine's Day 10
    In Between 8.5
    In Pieces 9.5
    The Little Things Give You Away 6.5
    No Roads Left 8

    A Thousand Suns 8.5/10
    Burning In The Skies 7.5
    When They Come For Me 7.5
    Robot Boy 7
    Waiting For The End 9.5
    Blackout 7
    Wretches And Kings 8.5
    Iridescent 8
    The Catalyst 9
    The Messenger 8
    Blackbirds 8.5

    Living Things 6.5/10
    Lost In The Echo 10
    In My Remains 8.5
    Burn It Down 6
    Lies Greed Misery 8
    I'll Be Gone 6.5
    Castle of Glass 5
    Victimized 6
    Roads Untraveled 8
    Skin To Bone 1 (WTF)
    Until It Breaks 7.5
    Tinfoil 8
    Powerless 7.5

    The Hunting Party 8/10
    Keys To The Kingdom 7.5
    All For Nothing 9
    Guilty All The Same 4
    War 4
    Wastelands 8
    Until It's Gone 9
    Rebellion 7.5
    Mark The Graves 1 (WTF)
    Drawbar 8
    Final Masquerade 9
    A Line In The Sand 8

    One More Light 8.5/10
    Nobody Can Save Me 10
    Good Goodbye 8
    Talking To Myself 6
    Battle Symphony 8.5
    Invisible 7
    Heavy 7.5
    Sorry For Now 7.5
    Halfway Right 8
    One More Light 10
    Sharp Edges 2
  7. #7

    Sonic Searching for the last Chaos Emerald... LPA Super Member

    Jul 26, 2004
    Likes Received:

    Hybrid Theory EP (6/10)
    01. Carousel (7.5)
    02. Technique [Short] (2)
    03. Step Up (6)
    04. And One (9)
    05. High Voltage (6.5)
    06. Part of Me (7)
    07. Ambient (4)

    Hybrid Theory (6.6/10)

    01. Papercut (8.5)
    02. One Step Closer (6)
    03. With You (10)
    04. Points of Authority (6.5)
    05. Crawling (5.5)
    06. Runaway (3)
    07. By Myself (5)
    08. In the End (7.5)
    09. A Place for My Head (8.5)
    10. Forgotten (7.5)
    11. Cure for the Itch (5)
    12. Pushing Me Away (6.5)

    Reanimation (5.5/10)

    01. Opening (8)
    02. Pts.of.Athrty (8)
    03. Enth E Nd [Feat. Motion Man] (7)
    04. [Chali] (1)
    05. Frgt/10 [Feat. Chali 2na] (9)
    06. P5hng Me A*wy [Feat. Stephen Richards] (10)
    07. Plc.4 Mie Hæd [Feat. Zion] (6)
    08. X-ecutioner Style [Feat. Black Thought] (4)
    09. H! Vltg3 [Feat. Pharoahe Monch] (3.5)
    10. [Riff Raff] (1)
    11. Wth>you [Feat. Aceyalone] (8)
    12. Ntr\mssion (3)
    13. Ppr:kut [Feat. Rasco & Planet Asia] (6.5)
    14. Rnw@y [Feat. Phoenix Orion] (3.5)
    15. My-Dsmbr [Feat. Kelli Ali] (4)
    16. [Stef] (1)
    17. By_Myslf (5)
    18. Kyur4 Th Ich (4.5)
    19. 1stp Klosr [Feat. Jonathan Davis] (9)
    20. Krwlng [Feat. Aaron Lewis] (7)

    Meteora (5.3/10)

    01. Foreward (2)
    02. Don't Stay (4)
    03. Somewhere I Belong (3)
    04. Lying From You (6)
    05. Hit the Floor (5)
    06. Easier to Run (4.5)
    07. Faint (7.5)
    08. Figure.09 (6)
    09. Breaking the Habit (8)
    10. From the Inside (7.5)
    11. Nobody's Listening (5)
    12. Session (6.5)
    13. Numb (4)

    Minutes to Midnight (7.6/10)

    01. Wake (5)
    02. Given Up (6)
    03. Leave Out All the Rest (9)
    04. Bleed it Out (7)
    05. Shadow of the Day (7)
    06. What I've Done (6)
    07. Hands Held High (10)
    08. No More Sorrow (8)
    09. Valentine's Day (9)
    10. In Between (6)
    11. In Pieces (8)
    12. The Little Things Give You Away (10)

    A Thousand Suns (7.7/10)

    01. The Requiem (9.5)
    02. The Radiance (7)
    03. Burning in the Skies (9)
    04. Empty Spaces (2)
    05. When They Come for Me (10)
    06. Robot Boy (9.5)
    07. Jornada del Muerto (7.5)
    08. Waiting for the End (8)
    09. Blackout (9.5)
    10. Wretches and Kings (8.5)
    11. Wisdom, Justice, and Love (5)
    12. Iridescent (8.5)
    13. Fallout (4.5)
    14. The Catalyst (10)
    15. The Messenger (7)

    Living Things (6/10)

    01. Lost in the Echo (7)
    02. In My Remains (8)
    03. Burn it Down (6)
    04. Lies Greed Misery (6)
    05. I'll Be Gone (4.5)
    06. Castle of Glass (7)
    07. Victimized (5.5)
    08. Roads Untraveled (6)
    09. Skin to Bone (7.5)
    10. Until it Breaks (6.5)
    11. Tinfoil (3)
    12. Powerless (4.5)

    The Hunting Party (6.4/10)

    01. Keys to the Kingdom (6)
    02. All for Nothing [Feat. Page Hamilton] (6.5)
    03. Guilty All the Same [Feat. Rakim] (8.5)
    04. The Summoning (2)
    05. War (2.5)
    06. Wastelands (7)
    07. Until it's Gone (6.5)
    08. Rebellion [Feat. Daron Malakian] (8.5)
    09. Mark the Graves (9.5)
    10. Drawbar [Feat. Tom Morello] (5)
    11. Final Masquerade (8)
    12. A Line in the Sand (7)

    One More Light (7.6/10)

    01. Nobody Can Save Me (8)
    02. Good Goodbye [Feat. Pusha T & Stormzy] (6)
    03. Talking to Myself (7)
    04. Battle Symphony (6.5)
    05. Invisible (9)
    06. Heavy [Feat. Kiiara] (5.5)
    07. Sorry for Now (9.5)
    08. Halfway Right (6)
    09. One More Light (10)
    10. Sharp Edges (8.5)

    My scores are interesting because, even though they're on par with how I feel about each album (as far as they're ranked here by their score), I feel like some of them are low just because a few songs bring them down. Oh well, fun though.
  8. #8
    LP Soldier 01

    LP Soldier 01 True LP Soldier

    Jun 27, 2017
    Likes Received:

    Hybrid Theory 8,08 (no song lower than 6, one of the most consistent ever)
    Papercut 7 (could be replaced by Runaway as a single)
    One Step Closer 7 (could be replaced by APFMH as a single)
    With You 9 (one of my HT favourites)
    Points of Authority 6 (one of the weakest of this legendary record)
    Crawling 9 (iconic one as well, but underrated in terms of views)
    Runaway 8,5 (should be a single for sure)
    By Myself 8 (very powerful one)
    In the End 10 (iconic song)
    A Place for My Head 10 (on my LP best songs)
    Forgotten 8 (another very powerful one)
    Cure for the Itch 8 (good DJ skills by Mr Hahn)
    Pushing Me Away 6,5 (one of the weakest slow songs by LP)

    Meteora 8,27 (more consistent than HT, LP best album)
    Don't Stay 8 (solid first song)
    Somewhere I Belong 8,5 (one of their all-time best)
    Lying from You 8 (solid, but could be better)
    Hit the Floor 8 (solid, but could be better)
    Easier to Run 8 (as good as SIB)
    Faint 9 (just a headbanger)
    Figure.09 8 (solid one)
    Breaking the Habit 10 (core song of the album, iconic as other ones)
    From the Inside 9 (very underrated one)
    Nobody's Listening 3 (only big letdown)
    Session 10 (that one is just insane)
    Numb 10 (iconic song)

    Minutes to Midnight 7,67 (is letdown a bit by songs like HHH and IB)
    Wake 9 (great intro)
    Given Up 8 (pretty good one)
    Leave Out All the Rest 10 (that one has sentimental value for me)
    Bleed It Out 7 (I feel it kind worn out already in shows, other that that great song)
    Shadow of the Day 8 (massively underrated song)
    What I've Done 9 (one of their best, but not perfect)
    Hands Held High 4 (can´t stand it)
    No More Sorrow 8 (very solid)
    Valentine's Day 10 (on my LP best songs)
    In Between 3 (can´t stand it either)
    In Pieces 10 (as well on my LP best songs)
    The Little Things Give You Away 6 (one of their weakest slow songs)

    A Thousand Suns 7,54 (the album with the most letdowns, but still good and some of the best songs)
    The Requiem 9 (almost perfect intro)
    The Radience 3 (irrelevant one)
    Burning in the Skies 8 (very consistent one, great Mike Shinoda singing)
    When They Come for Me 7 (pretty decent one)
    Robot Boy 10 (on my LP best songs)
    Waiting for the End 8 (very good one)
    Blackout 10 (another hell of a blast)
    Wretches and Kings 3 (can´t stand it)
    Iridescent 8.5 (one of their best slow songs ever)
    Fallout 7 (should be much longer, otherwise could be a solid 8)
    The Catalyst 10 (on my LP best songs)
    The Messenger 7 (better than the Little Things Give You Away and Pushing Me Away)

    Living Things 8,27 (actually like it better that HT at this point and almost like Meteora for top spot)
    Lost in the Echo 10 (great rap and Chester´s vocals)
    In My Remains 8,5 (very good one)
    Lies Greed Misery 4 (can´t stand this one, biggest letdown of LT)
    Burn It Down 10 (on LP best)
    I'll Be Gone 10 (just love that one)
    Castle of Glass 9 (same as IBG and BIT, some of best Mike Shinoda singing)
    Victimized 7,5 (very powerful, but too short)
    Roads Untraveled 10 (perfect one from this record)
    Skin to Bone 5 (very average)
    Until It Breaks 8 (great one)
    Tinfoil/Powerless 9 (one of their best slow songs)

    The Hunting Party 8,05
    Keys to the Kingdom 8 (Chester showing that he´s still got the screams)
    All for Nothing 5 (Page Hamilton didn´t work on this one as I see it)
    Guilty All the Same 6 (just don´t like Rakim, that´s why)
    War 7 (should be longer, but better than GATS)
    Wastelands 8,5 (ver powerful, glad they still play it live)
    Until It's Gone 9 (one of the most underrated songs, but for me it´s great and made me buy the album right away)
    Rebellion 10 (one of their best, also very underrated)
    Mark the Graves 8 (consistent but not as good as it could be)
    Drawbar 8 (great instrumental, but not perfect like Session was back in the day )
    Final Masquerade 10 (best of the album and among LP best, outweighs Rebellion by a tiny bit)
    A Line in the Sand 9 (one ofteir best songs to wrap up the record, just like Powerless in LT)

    One More Light 8,2 (now on my top 3 LP records after M and LT)
    Nobody Can Save Me 9 (grew a lot more on me after the instrumentals)
    Good Goodbye 7,5 (good, but could become much better with only Mike rapping, Pusha not that good and Stormzy just ok)
    Talking to Myself 8 (I´m impressed with the guitar work on this one, also has great energy live)
    Battle Symphony 7 (good lyrics and meaning, but too generic, slightly better than Heavy)
    Invisible 8,5 (a tiny bit better than TTM and SE)
    Heavy 6,5 (a bit worse than BS)
    Sorry for Now 10 (just perfect, the way Mike sings and the chpmunks are impressive, Chester´s rap is something to keep exploring)
    Halfway Right 7 (find the chipmunks and singing very good, just the lyrics don´t make sense to me, still better than Heavy and BS)
    One More Light 10 (this one spoke to me as no other LP song ever did, their most remarkable moment of the live shows currently)
    Sharp Edges 8,5 (grew a bit more on me after the instrumentals, great acoustic guitar work)

    So the list is as follows:
    M 8,29
    LT 8,27
    OML 8,2
    HT 8,08
    THP 8,05
    MTM 7,67
    ATS 7,54

    No album lower than 7, which is states just how good LP really is, some albums are just not higher because of some mistakes in some songs in every album, either because they should be longer, the people they worked with are not as good making music as LP are or some songs just went wrong. Actually my list took a slight turn from the one I had in my mind, but still the overall discography is simply outstanding.

Share This Page