Check out some of their older stuff like "Light Years Away" and "So Far, So Good". They used to be called Big Blue Monkey so check out some stuff under that name. "In Her Bedroom" is one of my favorites.
Yah if you have already heard three songs that you like i would just go and buy the album. Yah i saw Story of the Year a few years ago when nobody had really head of them and they put on one hell of a show. It was so sweet the one guitarist took off his guitar and threw it over to one of the guitar tech boys and then did a back flip on the stage with very little room. Then the guy threw him back his guitar and he picked up right back in the song. It was so amazing.