Hurt and Heal: The Hunting Party (Read the new rules)

Rebellion - 16 (-2)
Mark the Graves - 56 (+2)
Drawbar - 4
Final Masquerade - 47
A Line in the Sand - 58

 

Rebellion - 16
Mark the Graves - 58 (+2)
Drawbar - 2 (-2)
Final Masquerade - 47
A Line in the Sand - 58

 

Rebellion - 16
Mark the Graves - 58
Drawbar - 0 (-2) DEAD
Final Masquerade - 47
A Line in the Sand - 60 (+2)

 

Rebellion - 16
Mark the Graves - 58
Final Masquerade - 49 (+2)
A Line in the Sand - 58 (-2)

 

Okay, now that Drawbar is eliminated let's move this up to +3/-3 per @Mark's suggestion unless there are any objections.

This will hopefully make it go faster

 

Rebellion - 16
Mark the Graves - 55 (-3)
Final Masquerade - 52 (+3)
A Line in the Sand - 58

 

Rebellion - 13 (-3)
Mark the Graves - 55
Final Masquerade - 52
A Line in the Sand - 61 (+3)

 

Rebellion - 13
Mark the Graves - 58 (+3)
Final Masquerade - 53
A Line in the Sand - 57 (-3)

Last five tracks are top 5 tracks.
The Joesen One voted +2/-2.

 

Rebellion - 13
Mark the Graves - 61 (+3)
Final Masquerade - 53
A Line in the Sand - 54 (-3)

 

Rebellion - 13
Mark the Graves - 58 (-3)
Final Masquerade - 53
A Line in the Sand - 57 (+3)

 

Rebellion - 11 (-3)
Mark the Graves - 52
Final Masquerade - 56 (+3)
A Line in the Sand - 63

 

Rebellion - 10
Mark the Graves - 55 (+3)
Final Masquerade - 53 (-3)
A Line in the Sand - 63

 

Rebellion - 7 (-3)
Mark the Graves - 55
Final Masquerade - 56 (+3)
A Line in the Sand - 63

 

I'm honestly not sure the +3/-3 I'd helping much.

Once Rebellion is gone we might have to cut the points in half instead and go back to +1/-1 or +2/-2

I understand it caused some confusion last time but it might be necessary.

Thoughts?

If you guys wish to continue with Living Things after this someone else is taking over and doing that album.

 

It's the same because increasing and decreasing in the same proportion will always cause the game to proceed at the same pace. It would only be faster if you decreased more points in a song than you'd increase in other one, but that wouldn't be fair, so I see no problem in keeping +3/-3.

 

10 minutes early but I have to get back to work

Rebellion - 7
Mark the Graves - 58 (+3)
Final Masquerade - 56
A Line in the Sand - 60 (-3)