Hurt and Heal: The Hunting Party (Read the new rules)

Keys to the Kingdom - 1 (-1)
All for Nothing - 10
Guilty All the Same - 19
Until It’s Gone - 3 (+1)
Rebellion - 21
Mark the Graves - 35
Drawbar - 26
Final Masquerade - 29
A Line in the Sand - 35

 

PLEASE READ MY POST

Interesting PM from @Mark

"In the vein of making this easy and fun, can I suggest that you please institute a gradual increase in the +/- to make things quicker as time goes on. Perhaps after every two songs are eliminated, it increases by 1.

I've seen it done this way on countless other forums, and it's more efficient + cuts down on postwhoring. By the end of the contest, it means there isn't a divide that's going to take 200 posts to settle."

I think this is a good idea that could make the game go faster.

I'm eliminating KTTK as of this post, so once Until Its Gone dies, we would up the voting to +2/-2

How do people feel about this?

Keys to the Kingdom- 0 (-1) ELIMINATED
All for Nothing - 10
Guilty All the Same - 19
Until It’s Gone - 3
Rebellion - 21
Mark the Graves - 36 (+1)
Drawbar - 26
Final Masquerade - 29
A Line in the Sand - 35

 

All for Nothing - 10
Guilty All the Same - 19
Until It’s Gone - 3
Rebellion - 21
Mark the Graves - 35 (-1)
Drawbar - 26
Final Masquerade - 30 (+1)
A Line in the Sand - 35

I dig it @Blake

 

All for Nothing - 10
Guilty All the Same - 19
Until It’s Gone - 2 (-1)
Rebellion - 21
Mark the Graves - 35
Drawbar - 26
Final Masquerade - 30
A Line in the Sand - 36 (+1)

 

All for Nothing - 10
Guilty All the Same - 19
Until It’s Gone - 2
Rebellion - 21
Mark the Graves - 35
Drawbar - 26
Final Masquerade - 31 (+1)
A Line in the Sand - 35 (-1)

 

All for Nothing - 10
Guilty All the Same - 19
Until It’s Gone - 1 (-1)
Rebellion - 21
Mark the Graves - 35
Drawbar - 26
Final Masquerade - 31
A Line in the Sand - 36 (+1)

 

All for Nothing - 10
Guilty All the Same - 19
Until It’s Gone - 1
Rebellion - 21
Mark the Graves - 36 (+1)
Drawbar - 26
Final Masquerade - 30 (-1)
A Line in the Sand - 36

 

All for Nothing - 10
Guilty All the Same - 19
Until It’s Gone - 1
Rebellion - 21
Mark the Graves - 36
Drawbar - 26
Final Masquerade - 31 (+1)
A Line in the Sand - 35 (-1)

 

All for Nothing - 10
Guilty All the Same - 19
Until It’s Gone - 0 (-1) YOU DONT KNOW WHAT YOU'VE GOT UNTIL ITS GONE
Rebellion - 21
Mark the Graves - 36
Drawbar - 26
Final Masquerade - 31
A Line in the Sand - 36 (+1)

 

Okay, we are taking @Mark 's rule and putting in it place. If you guys are against it, let me know.

All for Nothing - 8 (-2)
Guilty All the Same - 19
Rebellion - 21
Mark the Graves - 38 (+2)
Drawbar - 26
Final Masquerade - 31
A Line in the Sand - 36

 

All for Nothing - 8
Guilty All the Same - 19
Rebellion - 21
Mark the Graves - 40 (+2)
Drawbar - 26
Final Masquerade - 31
A Line in the Sand - 34 (-2)

 

All for Nothing - 6 (-2)
Guilty All the Same - 19
Rebellion - 21
Mark the Graves - 40
Drawbar - 26
Final Masquerade - 33 (+2)
A Line in the Sand - 34

Still don't understand why Until It's Gone lost before All For Nothing, I like that song a lot.

 

All for Nothing - 6
Guilty All the Same - 19
Rebellion - 21
Mark the Graves - 40
Drawbar - 28 (+2)
Final Masquerade - 33
A Line in the Sand - 32 (-2)

 

All for Nothing - 6
Guilty All the Same - 19
Rebellion - 21
Mark the Graves - 38 (-2)
Drawbar - 28
Final Masquerade - 35 (+2)
A Line in the Sand - 32

 

All for Nothing - 6
Guilty All the Same - 19
Rebellion - 23 (+2)
Mark the Graves - 36 (-2)
Drawbar - 28
Final Masquerade - 35
A Line in the Sand - 32

 

All of the remaining songs are pretty good.

All for Nothing - 6
Guilty All the Same - 19
Rebellion - 23
Mark the Graves - 36
Drawbar - 28
Final Masquerade - 33 (-2)
A Line in the Sand - 34 (+2)

 

All for Nothing - 4 (-2)
Guilty All the Same - 19
Rebellion - 23
Mark the Graves - 36
Drawbar - 28
Final Masquerade - 35 (+2)
A Line in the Sand - 34

 

All for Nothing - 4
Guilty All the Same - 19
Rebellion - 23
Mark the Graves - 34 (-2)
Drawbar - 28
Final Masquerade - 37 (+2)
A Line in the Sand - 34

 

All for Nothing - 2 (-2)
Guilty All the Same - 19
Rebellion - 23
Mark the Graves - 36 (+2)
Drawbar - 28
Final Masquerade - 37 (+2)
A Line in the Sand - 34

 

All for Nothing - 0 (-2) It was All For Nothing trying to keep this song alive
Guilty All the Same - 19
Rebellion - 23
Mark the Graves - 36
Drawbar - 28
Final Masquerade - 37
A Line in the Sand - 36 (+2)