The Hunting Party Ranked

01. Final Masquerade
02. Keys To The Kingdom
03. All For Nothing
04. Rebellion
05. Wastelands

06. Guilty All The Same
07. A Line In The Sand

08. War
09. Mark The Graves
10. Drawbar
11. The Summoning
12. Until It's Gone

First bunch: great
Second bunch: okay
Third bunch: meh/don't care

 

At this moment:

1. Keys To The Kingdon
2. All For Nothing
3. Rebellion
4. Mark The Graves
5. GATS
6. The Summoning/ War
7. A Line In The Sand
8. Wastelands
9. Drawbar/Final Masquerade
10.Until It's Gone

 

1. Until It's Gone
2. A Line in the Sand
3. The Summoning/War
4. All For Nothing
5. Final Masquerade
6. Rebellion
7. Drawbar
8. Keys to the Kingdom
9. Mark the Graves
10. Guilty All the Same
11. Wastelands

 

Better songs came out

 

rebellion
mark the graves
guilty all the same
keys to the kingdom
war
a line in the sand
wastelands
final masquerade
all for nothing
until it's gone
drawbar
the summoning

 

After some more listens, my rankings changed a bit. Final Masquerade is a lot better than I originally thought, same with Mark the Graves. 4, 5, and 6 could be put in any order really.

1. Until It's Gone
2. Final Masquerade
3. A Line in the Sand
4. All For Nothing
5. The Summoning/War
6. Mark the Graves
7. Drawbar
8. Keys to the Kingdom
9. Rebellion
10. Guilty All the Same
11. Wastelands

 

I think it's been long enough that I can finally figure out where every track stands in my mind now.

1. Mark the Graves
2. Keys to the Kingdom
3/4. A Line in the Sand / Rebellion
5. Guilty All the Same
6. Drawbar
7. All For Nothing
8. The Summoning
9. War
10. Final Masquerade
11. Wastelands
12. Until It's Gone

 

My list now that the album has had time to sink in.

1. Final Masquerade
2. A Line In The Sand
3. Drawbar
4. Rebellion
5. Guilty All the Same
6. All For Nothing
7. Keys To The Kingdom
8. War
9. Until It's Gone
10. Wastelands
11. The Summoning
12. Mark The Graves

 

1. Rebellion
2. All For Nothing
3. Keys To The Kingdom
4. Guilty All The Same
5. A Line In The Sand
6. Mark The Graves
7. Wastelands
8. War
9. Final Masquerade
10. Until It's Gone
11. Drawbar
12. The Summoning

 

1. Keys To The Kingdom
2. Mark The Graves
3. War
4. Final Masquerade
5. Rebellion
6. A Line In The Sand
7. Guilty All The Same
8. All For Nothing
9. Drawbar
10. Wastelands
11. Until It's Gone
12. The Summoning

Speaking of ranking songs, is Kacy/Minus/Coldplay ever gonna start his tier thread for this album?

 

i. until it's gone
ii. drawbar

i. all for nothing
ii. a line in the sand

i. final masquerade

i. wastelands

i. keys to the kingdom
ii. guilty all the same
iii. rebellion
iv. mark the graves

i. the summoning
ii. war

 

Keys To The Kingdom / Final Masquerade / Mark The Graves

Guilty All The Same / The Summoning / War / Rebellion

Until It's Gone / A Line In The Sand / Drawbar

Wastelands / All For Nothing

 

Final Masquerade

Keys to the Kingdom, All for Nothing

A Line In the Sand, Mark the Graves

Rebellion, Wastelands, Guilty All the Same

Until It's Gone

War

The Summoning, Drawbar

 

"Mark the Graves" | "A Line in the Sand"

"Rebellion" | "Drawbar"

"Keys to the Kingdom" | "Guilty All the Same" | "War"

"All for Nothing" | "Final Masquerade"

"Wastelands"

"Until It's Gone"

~

Not including "The Summoning" because I don't see it as a track that should be judged separately.

 

1. Keys to the Kingdom
2. Guilty All the Same
3. Rebellion
4. A Line in the Sand
5. Wastelands
6. Until It's Gone
7. All For Nothing
8. War
9. Final Masquerade
10. Mark the Graves