The Official LPA "The Hunting Party" Tier List

So I remember back when LT came out, Minus (Coldplay) made a LT Tier List which was pretty cool. Thought we should do it again. I'm just gonna copy the description off that thread:

There are 6 tiers in which a song can be rated. It's purely subjective to your own point of view. I'll be compiling the overall opinions of the forum via a point system and updating this post with a definitive tier list.

GOD TIER (SS TIER) - This is reserved for songs that you consider a complete mastery of music. If you can't think of anything WRONG with the song, it goes here. Worth 5 points.
S TIER - Songs that are just short of perfection are S Tier. Worth 4 points.
A TIER - This is for songs that are great but have shortcomings that prevent it from reaching near-perfection. Worth 3 points.
B TIER - Good songs that have the potential to be great, but fall short. Worth 2 points.
C TIER - This is for songs that you are ambivalent towards. The best description here is "average". You skip these songs about 50% of the time. Worth 1 point.
F TIER - You just don't like these songs. At all. These songs are the ones you skip without fail. Worth nothing.

So let's see your tiers!

How are you calculating the overall song tiers?
We're using a method called median. You've probably heard about it in school. Basically, you list out all your ratings in order like so:

1, 3, 4, 4, 4, 5, 5​

Then you choose the middle number. In this case, it's 4.


SO LET'S GO!


EDIT: DEADLINE: 30th June (should be enough time, right?)

 

GOD TIER (SS TIER) - Keys to the Kingom, Mark The Graves
S TIER - Guilty All The Same, War, Rebellion, Drawbar
A TIER - All for Nothing, Wastelands,
B TIER - The Summoning, Until It's Gone, Final Masquerade, A Line in the Sand
C TIER -
F TIER -

I tried to be a bit more critical this time.

 

God Tier - Final Masquerade, Mark The Graves, A Line In The Sand
S Tier - Keys To The Kingdom, War, Rebellion
A Tier - All For Nothing, Until It's Gone
B Tier - Guilty All The Same, The Summoning
C Tier - Drawbar, Wastelands
F Tier -

 

GOD TIER (SS TIER) - All For Nothing, A Line In The Sand, Rebellion, Final Masquerade, Keys To The Kingdom
S TIER - Guilty All The Same, Until It's Gone, War, Mark The Graves
A TIER - Wastelands, Drawbar, The Summoning
B TIER -
C TIER -
F TIER -

 

After some 10 listens of the albums...

GOD TIER (SS TIER)

- Keys to the Kingdom
- Summoning / War
- Mark the Graves
- A Line in the Sand

S TIER

- Rebellion
- Drawbar

A TIER

- All For Nothing
- Guilty all the Same
- Final Masquerade

B TIER

- Wastelands
- Until It's Gone

C TIER
F TIER

 

GOD TIER (SS TIER) - , A Line In The Sand, Rebellion, Final Masquerade, Keys To The Kingdom Mark the graves
S TIER - Guilty All The Same, , War, All For Nothing Wastelands
A TIER - ,Until It's Gone
B TIER - The Summoning
C TIER - Drawbar
F TIER -

 

GOD TIER (SS TIER) - Keys To The Kingdom, Mark The Graves, Guilty All The Same
S TIER - Rebellion, A Line In The Sand, Drawbar, Final Masquerade
A TIER - All For Nothing, War
B TIER - Until It's Gone
C TIER - Wastelands
F TIER - The Summoning(It was cool the first time but it doesn't even work as a build up for War, so what is the point in hearing it again?)

 

GOD TIER (SS TIER) - Keys To The Kingdom, All For Nothing, Mark The Graves, Rebellion, A Line In The Sand
S TIER - Guilty All The Same, The Summoning, War, Drawbar
A TIER - Until It's Gone, Final Masquerade, Wastelands
B TIER -
C TIER -
F TIER

 

GOD TIER (SS TIER) - Keys to the Kingdom, Until It's Gone, A Line in the Sand
S TIER - Rebellion, Final Masquerade
A TIER - All For Nothing, Guilty All The Same
B TIER - Wastelands, Drawbar
C TIER - War, Mark the Graves
F TIER - The Summoning

 

GOD TIER (SS TIER) - Keys to the Kingdom, Rebellion, Mark The Graves, A Line in the Sand
S TIER - Guilty All The Same, Final Masquerade, Wastelands, War, Until It's Gone
A TIER -
B TIER - Drawbar
C TIER - The Summoning, All For Nothing
F TIER

 

GOD TIER (SS TIER) - Keys To The Kingdom, Mark The Graves, Wastelands
S TIER - Final Masquerade, Rebellion, Drawbar, A Line In The Sand
A TIER - Guilty All The Same, Until It's Gone, War
B TIER - All For Nothing
C TIER - The Summoning
F TIER -

 

I don't know if I will not change my opinion... You only live once.

GOD TIER (SS TIER)

- Keys To The Kingdom
- Guilty All The Same
- Wastelands
- Final Masquerade
- A Line In The Sand

S TIER

- All For Nothing
- War
- Drawbar

A TIER

- Rebellion
- Until It's Gone

B TIER

C TIER

- Mark The Graves
- The Summoning

F TIER

 

GOD TIER (SS TIER)
- Rebellion
- Final Masquerade
- All For Nothing
- Until It's Gone

S TIER
- Keys To The Kingdon

A TIER
- Wastelands
- Guilty All The Same

B TIER -
- Mark The Graves
- War
- A Line In The Sand
- Drawbar
- The Summoning

C TIER -

F TIER -

 

GOD TIER (SS TIER) - Final Masquerade, Rebellion,
S TIER - Drawbar, Until It’s Gone,
A TIER - All For Nothing, Guilty All The Same, A Line In The Sand,
B TIER -Keys To The Kingdom, The Summoning, Mark The Graves, Wastelands,
C TIER - War,
F TIER - None

Wastelands is somewhere between B and C tier, and Rebellion is somewhere between GOD and S tier, and I decided to round them both up. That was harder to do after only a few listens than I would've thought.

 

I'll be creating a spreadsheet for this.

 

GOD TIER (SS TIER)
- Mark the Graves

S TIER
- A Line in the Sand
- Keys to the Kingdom

A TIER
- War
- Wastelands

B TIER
- Guilty all the Same
- Final Masquerade
- Rebellion

C TIER
- Drawbar
- All For Nothing
- Until It's Gone

F TIER
- The Summoning

 

GOD TIER (SS TIER) - Final Masquerade
S TIER - Rebellion
A TIER - Guilty All The Same, All For Nothing, Wastelands
B TIER - A Line In The Sand, Keys To The Kingdom
C TIER - Drawbar, The Summoning
F TIER - Until It's Gone, War, Mark The Graves

 

Also Krishnan, you jumped the gun. I was delaying creating a thread for this because I wanted to redo the tiers and ask for additional information. There's too big of a leap between C and F in terms of enjoyment.

 

we should do one Tier list for every album

GOD TIER
Keys to the Kingom, Mark The Graves
S TIER
A Line In The Sand, Final Masquerade
A TIER
Rebellion, Drawbar
B TIER
Wastelands, Guilty All The Same, War
C TIER
Until It's Gone, The Summoning
F TIER
All For Nothing

 

GOD TIER (SS TIER) - A Line In The Sand, Final Masquerade, Keys To The Kingdom
S TIER - War, Rebellion, Mark The Graves, (Feat. Daron Malakian)
A TIER - All For Nothing (Feat. Page Hamilton), Drawbar (Feat. Tom Morello)
B TIER - The Summoning
C TIER - Guilty All The Same (Feat. Rakim), Until It's Gone, Wastelands
F TIER -

I'm curious about the final results.
[video=youtube;-Fh_liyhIH8]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Fh_liyhIH8[/video]