Why do you look at me like that Like you know all my secrets As if you know about him We were fine in the beginning Flirtation, kisses, the works But the minute you asked me That question I felt it happen It was like a tight thread snapping It was like a torrent of water Pouring over my heart Because that's what it took For me to realize that I loved him Why is it so hard to say The things you want to say most Why do the people you try to keep out Wind up in the middle of your heart I tried to prevent it But I couldn't help it I was lost in his dark gaze I tried to apologize But no one would listen Stuck in their stereotype of me I know you feel bad, maybe thinking "If I had treated her better, If I had loved her more" But it wouldn't have helped I know you are confused "Why, of all people, Did she go to my best friend?" But it couldn't have been prevented I don't understand what drew me to him He doesn't understand what drew him to me Nobody understands what we are together It's like two shadows joining together It's like two people that were invisible being seen Suddenly by all Wondering why they hadn't seen it coming When I was upset, he was the one I talked to Not you, but why not? I just feel uncomfortable thinking of you When all I wanted to dream about was him Why is it so hard to say The things you want to say most Why do the people you try to keep out Wind up in the middle of your heart