The Official LPA LIVING THINGS Tier List

[danielpsoad-09]

GOD TIER - Castle Of Glass, Lost In the Echo, Tinfoil/Powerless, In My Remains

S TIER - Roads Untraveled, Victimized

A TIER - Burn It Down, Skin To Bone, I'll Be Gone

B TIER - Until It Breaks

C TIER - Lies Greed Misery

F TIER - None

[Spiderguy252]

Burn it Down deserves an F, frankly.

[lepetitpote]

God Tier - Lost in the Echo, Castle of Glass, Tinfoil/Powerless, I'll Be Gone

S Tier - Victimized, Skin to Bone, Lies Greed Misery, In My Remains

A Tier - Roads Untraveled, Until it Breaks

B Tier -

C Tier - Burn it Down

F Tier -

[cloudscream]

SS TIER
Until It Breaks

S TIER
Lost in the Echo, Roads Untraveled, Castle of Glass, Skin to Bone

A TIER
Victimized, Tinfoil

B TIER
Lies Greed Misery, In My Remains, I'll Be Gone, Powerless

C TIER
Burn It Down

F TIER
---

[~xXmEt30R4_1Uv3r_03.23.03Xx~]

Burn it Down deserves an F, frankly.

That's your opinion, and in this thread it doesn't really count unless you do a complete tier list.

[travz21]

TITTY TIER
Roads Untraveled

S TIER
Until It Breaks, Skin To Bone, Lost In The Echo

A TIER
Tinfoil/Powerless, In My Remains, I'll Be Gone, Castle Of Glass

B TIER
Victimized, Burn It Down, Lies Greed Misery

C TIER
---

F TIER
---

[theycallmepraya]

GOD TIER
Roads Untraveled, I'll Be Gone, Tinfoil/Powerless, Lost In The Echo

S TIER
Victimized, In My Remains

A TIER
Until It Breaks, Castle of Glass, Skin to Bone

B TIER
Burn It Down

C TIER
Lies Greed Misery

F TIER
Call Me, Maybe?

[_Depression]

I might actually add an x-axis to rate consistency. For example, Roads Untraveled would be on the far right whereas a song like Until It Breaks would be on the left. Something like the average of the highest and lowest score. Roads Untraveled would be rated at a 4 (the sum of 5 and 3 divided by 2) whereas Until It Breaks would be rated at a 2.5 ([5+0]/2). I'm aware of the flaws in this (Burn It Down is at a 2, but is consistent in scores) and will think of a better system later.

EDIT: Possibly taking that high-low average and dividing it by the tiered average? In this case, Roads Untraveled would be a 0.875 whereas Burn It Down would be a 1.17? If you see any flaws, let me know!

What about letting the song stray on the X-axis based on whether the bulk of votes are above or below the tier average. For example, if a song gets 9 votes for B Tier and 3 votes for GOD tier, that averages out to a 2.7 which is basically a 3. But because the majority of votes tend toward the negative (below the average), the X-value would trend that way. I don't have any good formula to find exactly how _far_ it should trend, but yeah.

[~xXmEt30R4_1Uv3r_03.23.03Xx~]

One more update before I get to sleep. I've figured out how I want to do the x-axis mentioned early for the graph.

To prevent a single 0 for a song to completely affect consistency (all 5s and one 0 for example would make it appear less consistent than the song actually is), I will be dropping the lowest and highest score. So in a list of say, 0, 4, 5, 5, 5, I'd drop the 0 and one of the 5s then take the NEW low and high for the average that eventually is used in the consistency formula.

Until then, I'm getting to sleep.

EDIT: _Depression, your idea has merit. I'll try both formulas out tomorrow morning (read: in 5 hours or so) and see which yields better results.

[Spiderguy252]

That's your opinion, and in this thread it doesn't really count unless you do a complete tier list.

GOD TIER
-

S TIER
Lost in the Echo, Until it Breaks

A TIER
I'll Be Gone, Powerless (& Tinfoil)

B TIER
Lies Greed Misery, In my Remains, Castle of Glass, Roads Untravelled

C TIER
Skin to Bone, Victimized

F TIER
Burn it Down

[Blake]

GOD TIER
Castle of Glass, Lost in The Echo, Skin to Bone, Lies Greed Misery, Roads Untraveled

S TIER
In My Remains, I'll Be Gone, Victimized, Powerless

A TIER
Tinfoil, Burn it Down

B TIER
- none

C TIER
Until It Breaks

F TIER
-none

[Dragonfly]

GOD TIER
Lost in the Echo, In My Remains, Burn It Down, Lies Greed Misery, I'll Be Gone, Castle of Glass, Victimized, Roads Untraveled, Skin To Bone, Until It Breaks, Tinfoil, Powerless

S TIER
---

A TIER
---

B TIER
---

C TIER
---

F TIER
---

[Filip]

GOD TIER
Castle of Glass, Skin To Bone, Lost In The Echo, Lies Greed Misery

S TIER
Victimized, In My Remains, Powerless, I'll Be Gone

A TIER
Roads Untraveled, Burn It Down, Until It Breaks

B TIER
---

C TIER
---

F TIER
Tinfoil

[iamsatan]

GOD TIER
Lost in the Echo, Powerless

S TIER
In My Remains, Castle of Glass, Victimized

A TIER
Until it Breaks, Skin To Bone, Roads Untraveled

B TIER
Lies Greed Misery, Tinfoil

C TIER
Burn it Down, I'll Be Gone

F TIER
---

[Knt.Slbs]

GOD TIER
CASTLE OF GLASS, TINFOIL/POWERLESS, VICTIMIZED

S TIER
ROADS UNTRAVELED, SKIN TO BONE, LOST IN THE ECHO

A TIER
IN MY REMAINS, I'LL BE GONE, BURN IT DOWN

B TIER
LIES GREED MISERY

C TIER
UNTIL IT BREAKS

F TIER
-NONE-

[Adiek84]

GOD TIER
LOST IN THE ECHO, CASTLE OF GLASS, LIES GREED MISERY

S TIER
IN MY REMAINS,VICTIMIZED, UNTIL IT BREAKS, SKIN TO BONE, ROADS UNTRAVELED


A TIER
I'LL BE GONE, TINFOIL/POWERLESS


B TIER
BURN IT DOWN

C TIER
--

F TIER

--

I love Dragonfly's list

[Jesse]

I'm on a phone so no fancy colours for now.

ODIN TIER
CASTLE OF GLASS, ROADS UNTRAVELED, UNTIL IT BREAKS. (5 points)

S TIER
SKIN TO BONE, VICTIMIZED. (4 points)

A TIER
IN MY REMAINS, POWERLESS/TINFOIL. (3 points)

B TIER
I'll BE GONE. (2 points)

C TIER
BURN IT DOWN, LIES GREED MISERY, LOST IN THE ECHO. (1 point)

F TIER

[The Prisoner]

GOD TIER
ROADS UNTRAVELED, SKIN TO BONE, UNTIL IT BREAKS, CASTLE OF GLASS

S TIER
TINFOIL/POWERLESS, VICTIMIZED

A TIER
I'LL BE GONE, IN MY REMAINS, LOST IN THE ECHO

B TIER
BURN IT DOWN

C TIER
LIES GREED MISERY

F TIER
---

[Death Slayer]

GOD TIER
Lost In The Echo, Castle Of Glass, Tinfoil/Powerless

S TIER
In My Remains

A TIER
Burn It Down, I'll Be Gone, Lies Greed Misery, Roads Untraveled

B TIER
I'll Be Gone, Victimized, Skin To Bone

C TIER
Until It Breaks

F TIER
---

[AkirraKrylon]

God Tier
Lost In The Echo, Castle of Glass, Until It Breaks, Tinfoil/Powerless

S Tier
In My Remains, Lies Greed Misery, I'll Be Gone, Victimized, Roads Untraveled, Skin To Bone

A Tier
Burn It Down