With You. a lot of the songs listed honestly don't sound the greatest live. however, it would probably be cool if they gave In Pieces another try. Chester has really been back on top of his game lately, as opposed to 07/08 when he was a bit off.
What about And One? Carousel? Reading My Eyes? They should play things like QWERTY too. Pretend to Be and What We Don't Know because they've never played those ones live.
If they want high-energy concerts, In Pieces which was my initial vote. If they want to kind of keep that energy, and throw a shout-out to old schoolers, With You.
In Pieces all the way, that would make an amazing song live, especially with added bits.. like a intro / outro.. more verses or a longer solo or medley or something, that would be awesome.