 |
So I guess you all know there has been people saying that these two songs are very similar. Do you think they really are?
I think there's two similar things:
1. they're both epic
2. the outro (in "What I've Done" it's really the outro, but in "New Divide" it's a part of the chorus - that is sung a capella with the guitar in the background)
But overall, I don't think they're that similar. Especially the themes of the lyrics are very different.
I kind of see how people say that there identical.
One song is really bad and one is just average.
Which one do you think is bad and which one do you think is just average?Originally Posted by travz21
What I've Done is so bland and unoriginal. New Divide has more interesting elements involved with the instrumental.
The song structures are completely identical. From the slow drum buildup, the hard rock intro, soft verses with energetic choruses that lead into a stripped down bridge, followed by the chorus repeated until the end.
They even end the same. "Whaaaat I've Doneeeee..." vs "Across this new divideeeeeee....". That's why there's mashups combining the two. They're near blatant copies of eachother.
The LPA is self funded and does not host advertising on our front page. Therefore all server costs/maintenance fees are paid out of our own pockets to keep this site available to our visitors and to keep down times to a minimum. Please consider helping with our hosting costs by donating a few dollars ($5, $10, $15 - anything) through the button below. Your support and help with the site will be greatly appreciated.
HELP THE LPA:
They pulled in Infinity Ward. Bastards.
these words of wisdom come with lack of vision
this is the worst day i've ever had to stand and witness
The guitar parts in both songs are pretty much identical too.
Gosh, people, I thought you like Linkin Park.
"New Divide" is much more moody, for sure. And it has much more electronica, expecially Joe's breakdown, while there's barely some electronica in "What I've Done". I don't know. I just don't think they're that similar.
Did the band ever comment these comparisons?
Last edited by Utterly Boring; 02-26-2012 at 05:42 AM.
There are much more similarity between Crawling/Easier To Run/Numb.
In Linkin Park's defense, it must be pretty difficult to make a new song that sounds nothing like, or even close to, anything you've made before. The similarities are there, especially with the bridge, but New Divide was made specifically for the sequel to Transformers so maybe it's a sequel to What I've Done.
No. Crawling is one of the most unique Linkin Park songs and should not be compared to Easier to Run only because they both start with the chorus. Numb? Really?
The reason the two sound so familiar is because of their chord progression. They're identical. New Divide's chords are 2 semitones lower than WID. Burning in the Skies is also identical to these two but it is pitched 2 semitones higher than WID...
I don't think their 100% identical, but their very similar. New Divide is more interesting structure wise compared to What I've done:
New Divide: Intro>Verse>double chorus>verse>single chorus>heavy breakdown>Bridge>breakdown>single chorus>outro
What I've Done: Intro>Verse>chorus>verse>chorus>bridge>breakdown>c horus>outro
WID has a more generic formula to me.
Fuck off.
I see what you mean though.
Just because you like a band doesn't mean that you ignore the fact that 2 songs are identical.
Last edited by Super Sonic; 02-26-2012 at 07:38 PM.
very identical songs... but very different meaning, in the end both epic for me
I know. But they're not. At least for me.
They're damn near the same song. Previous posts point to the similar structure and lyrical delivery, but they also carry a very similar meaning (a narrator speaking of regrets as he bridges a transition into a new beginning). "New Divide" functions slightly better on account of its atmospheric instrumentation, lyrics, and unique breakdown.
Should've made this thread a poll. ;P
This would be a pure disaster
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
